UK prime minister accused of ‘belittling antisemitism’ as Palestine Solidarity Campaign says Nakba Day march will go ahead.
A coalition of campaign groups organising pro-Palestine marches in the UK has criticised attempts by politicians and the media to smear the demonstrations, as well as suggestions they could be banned.
Confirming that the planned Nakba Day demonstration in London will go ahead on 16 May, the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC), Stop the War Coalition, Friends of Al-Aqsa and other groups stated on Friday night that “the right to protest is a fundamental freedom”.
“In the wake of the horrific antisemitic attack in Golders Green, politicians and the media have rushed to falsely characterise the marches for Palestine and to call for them to be suppressed,” PSC said.
“These calls dangerously conflate Jewish people with the state of Israel and peaceful political protest with unconnected violent acts. We utterly reject both.”
A 45-year-old Somali-born British national was arrested on Wednesday afternoon after the stabbing of two Jewish men, aged 34 and 76, in Golders Green, a neighbourhood of northwest London with a large Jewish population.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters.
Essa Suleiman is also accused of attempting to murder Ishmail Hussein, a Muslim man he had known for about 20 years, earlier that day.
On Friday, London’s Metropolitan Police announced that Suleiman, who was released from a psychiatric hospital just days before the attacks, had been charged not with terrorism offences, but with three counts of attempted murder and one count of possession of a bladed article in a public place.
Politicians, including British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, have used the Golders Green attacks to condemn pro-Palestine marches and call for their curtailment.
In an interview with the BBC’s Today programme on Saturday, Starmer said the language used on marches should be policed and suggested that there could be a case for banning marches altogether.
“I think when you hear some of those chants – ‘globalise the intifada’ would be the one I would pick out – then clearly there should be tougher action in relation to that,” Starmer said.
‘These calls dangerously conflate Jewish people with the state of Israel and peaceful political protest with unconnected violent acts. We utterly reject both’
There have been no recorded incidents in the UK of an antisemitic attack involving the phrase “globalise the intifada”. However, in December, the Metropolitan and Greater Manchester police forces announced they would arrest people for chanting the phrase or holding placards displaying it.
Asked about calls – including from Jonathan Hall, the government’s independent reviewer of terrorism legislation – for a “moratorium” on pro-Palestine marches, Starmer said: “I think it’s time to look across the board at protests and the cumulative effect.”
“In relation to the repeated nature of the marches, many people in the Jewish community have said to me, it’s the repeat nature, it’s the cumulative effect,” the prime minister said.
“Now, I accept that, which is why we intend to deal with cumulative effects.”
Starmer said his government needed to “look at what further powers we can take” regarding the protests. “I’m not saying, of course, that there aren’t very strong, legitimate views about the Middle East, about Gaza. We all have deep concerns about it.”
Starmer condemned
On Friday, a senior rabbi in north London rejected any connection between the pro-Palestine marches and Wednesday’s stabbing attack.
“It is certainly not the marches that caused the tragic stabbing attacks on Wednesday in Golders Green,” Herschel Gluck told Middle East Eye.
‘Demanding Israel stops its genocidal rampage on Palestine is clearly not antisemitic, and by trying to draw the comparison, Starmer is belittling antisemitism’
He said that banning the marches over antisemitism concerns would be an own goal because of the large number of Jews who regularly took part in the protests.
“There are many Jews who participate in the marches. Pro rata, there are more Jews than any other community. And the idea of banning speech is something that is a very un-Jewish thing to do.”
Campaign groups condemned Starmer’s remarks and the suggestion that marches could be banned.
Lindsey German, convenor of Stop the War Coalition, told MEE: “Keir Starmer talks about banning marches and slogans, falsely claiming they increase threats of antisemitism.
“The marches are protests at the role of the Israeli government in its genocidal attacks on Gaza, and at the complicity of Starmer’s own government in supporting Israel.”
“This is an attack on our freedom of speech and long-held right to assembly, and we will not give up that right,” German said.
Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, told MEE: “Starmer’s interview this weekend is as cynical as it is dangerous.”
“Instead of lowering the heat and fostering unity, he is fostering division in a desperate attempt to avoid electoral defeat,” he said, referring to upcoming local elections on 7 May.
“Demanding Israel stops its genocidal rampage on Palestine is clearly not antisemitic, and by trying to draw the comparison, Starmer is belittling antisemitism,” Dearden said.
Read More »
“Starmer’s government is utterly complicit in Israel’s war crimes. He has blood on his hands and now risks further fuelling antisemitism, rather than taking the important steps necessary to undermine it.”
Ben Jamal, director of PSC, said: “Those who utilise individual acts of racist violence to justify the denial of basic democratic freedoms, including the right to protest, diminish rather than advance the antiracist struggle.”
Daniel Levy, a British Israeli analyst and former adviser to the Israeli government, called the suggestion that there should be a moratorium on freedom of expression “appalling”.
“That sounds like something that would encourage more antisemitism. You can’t have a false dichotomy between Jewish safety and Palestinian rights,” Levy told Channel 4 News.
“First, we’ll be told you can’t protest on this, and then you won’t be able to protest on anything, and then we’re living in a fundamentally different society.”
Nakba march against Tommy Robinson
In its statement, PSC and the coalition organising the marches said that on 16 May “we will march in London for the annual commemoration of the Nakba – the catastrophe inflicted on the Palestinians by Israel since 1948”.
“We will march in opposition to the British government’s complicity in Israel’s well-documented ethnic cleansing, apartheid and genocide,” the groups said.
They added that this year’s march would also be held against far-right British agitator Tommy Robinson and his supporters, who have planned a “Unite the Kingdom” march on the same day.
PSC said that “as always, our march will involve thousands of Jewish people – many of them proudly displaying their Jewish identity – as part of the Jewish Bloc, as organisers and platform speakers”.
Israel’s genocide in Gaza began following the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October 2023. Medical officials in Gaza say the death toll is now at least 72,601, with 172,419 people wounded since 7 October 2023.
Since the ceasefire agreed on 11 October last year, Israel has killed at least 824 people and 2,316 wounded, according to health authorities. Rescue teams have also recovered 764 bodies from beneath destroyed buildings.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.
#PalestineSolidarity #KeirStarmer #NakbaDay #RightToProtest #Gaza #Antisemitism #UKPolitics #FreedomOfSpeech #GoldersGreen #IsraelPalestineConflict
